Baltimore (410) 837-0290
Washington, D.C./Chevy Chase (301) 718-4825
Northern Virginia (703) 714-9553
Go Back
Bling Central

Selling Your Diamonds

Sep 4, 2010

There’s a lot info online about buying diamonds, but not as much about selling unwanted diamonds and jewelry. Whether you’re in Baltimore, Maryland, Washington DC or Virginia, we strive to make selling your diamonds, gold or estate jewelry as easy and as educational as possible. It does not have to be an intimidating experience at all. In fact, here at Samuelson’s Diamonds, we explain, with full disclosure, the market on your diamond, what you can expect to get for it, and WHY.

Round Brilliant Cut Diamond

Round Brilliant Cut Diamond

The price given to a customer when buying their diamond is determined by these factors: (in no particular order)

1) Quality: cut, color and clarity. Most often, people have appraisals and lab reports with diamond grades on them. However, one must remember that an appraisal or lab report is only subjective – it’s done by humans, not a machine. The question that I personally ask myself  when buying a diamond is simply, “Is this a diamond that I want to own?” And that can just be a feeling or something about that diamond that I like (or don’t like). For all of you in the market to buy a diamond, that’s a question that you should be asking yourself as I explained in this blog post, “How To Look At A Diamond”.

2) Shape: Most people do not realize that some diamond shapes are in demand and some are just not. Rounds are always in demand and salable, but marquises and heart shapes are generally not in demand. (until you get to larger sizes) So, for example, you will get more when you are selling a 2 carat G, SI1 quality round diamond, and not as much for the same exact size and quality in a marquise diamond. It’s not to say that there is anything wrong with your diamond, it’s just simple economics. If we buy a marquise, our cash will be tied up for a long time since there are few customers buying that diamond shape.

3) Carat Weight: It’s pretty obvious that a 3 carat diamond is generally going to be worth more than a 1 carat diamond. Of course, if the larger diamond is very poor quality, it may not be desirable at all. One thing that diamond sellers should be aware of when talking about carat weight – the center/primary diamond is where the main value is. So a 3 carat solitaire diamond will be worth more than a ring with ten diamonds that equal 3 carats TOTAL WEIGHT. Just something to think about.

4) Inventory Levels: If we have 20 one carat princess cut diamonds in stock, and you have a one carat princess cut diamond to sell, we may simply not need your stone in our inventory. Our store inventory often reflects overall diamond market levels in certain shapes and qualities, so sometimes a common diamond that is very easily accessible will not bring as much.

5) Market conditions: Although the diamond market has actually held strong and steady in this very difficult economic climate, there are still a lot of diamond suppliers that are either: a) holding too much inventory or b) are short on cash and are owed a lot of money from failing retailers. In 2008 and 2009 here a some companies that either filed for Chapter 11 or simply went under – Fortunoff, Whitehall Jewelers, Robbin Bros, Robbins Diamonds and Robbins Delaware Diamonds, Shane Co, Bailey, Banks and Biddle (a division of Zale Corp), David Webb, Fred Leighton – you get the picture. So the bottom line is that if you have CASH, you can get pretty good prices on diamonds. And something very important to remember is that we can’t buy diamonds from the public for more than what we can acquire them for in the open market.

That said, the good news is that we always have the cash to buy your diamonds! (or gold/estate jewelry). And we pay the most for diamonds in Baltimore, Washington DC and Northern Virginia.

All of these factors are explained to each and every customer that we buy jewelry from so it makes sense, so please don’t hesitate to contact us or stop by to sell your jewelry!

Read The Latest News From Samuelson's

History of The Diamond as an Engagement Ring

Oct 4, 2021

History of The Diamond as an Engagement Ring If you’ve ever heard Beyonce’s “Single Ladies,” you’re familiar with the refrain, “If you liked it, then you shoulda put a ring on it.” But where does the idea of putting a ring on it come…

Read More

The Scoop on Precious Metals

Sep 20, 2021

Scoop on Precious Metals Just about every piece of jewelry contains a precious metal. Same goes for old coins, watches, and silverware. But what makes them “precious” exactly?  Precious metals are elemental metals that are naturally occurring…

Read More

Hand Sanitizer and Fine Jewelry

Sep 8, 2021

Hand Sanitizer and Fine Jewelry Chances are, you have hand sanitizer in your purse, pocket, or glove compartment — and with good reason! With the Covid-19 pandemic still hanging around, better safe than sorry. However, one thing most people haven’t…

Read More

All About Type IIA Diamonds

Aug 24, 2021

All About Type IIA Diamonds Most people stumble across the 4 C’s of a diamond when researching an engagement ring. After all, those play a major factor in determining a diamond’s value and cost. But some people like to take it a step further —…

Read More

Stay In Touch

Shopping Cart

Search